Coming up Wednesday

Wildfires burn through Colorado causing thousands to evacuate, and protests in Turkey are in 13th day. Tune in at 7am ET.
July 5th, 2012
08:57 AM ET

UPDATED: Obama campaign rep LaBolt: President disagrees with Court on 'tax,' views health care mandate as a penalty

From CNN's Kevin Liptak via Political Ticker

(CNN) – President Barack Obama's campaign spokesman said Thursday that Obama disagrees with the Supreme Court's characterization of his health care law's individual mandate as a tax.

Ben LaBolt, appearing on CNN's "Starting Point with Soledad O'Brien," said Obama still believes the fee assessed to people who choose not to obtain health insurance should be classified as a "penalty" rather than a "tax."

"You saw our arguments before the Supreme Court," LaBolt said. "You see what the president has said over the past several years that it's a penalty for that 1% of the population who can afford health insurance but hasn't chosen to get it."

Asked whether Obama "disagrees with the Supreme Court decision that says it's now a tax," LaBolt said "that's right."

"He's said it was a penalty," LaBolt continued. "You saw our arguments before the court."

LaBolt asserted that the government's lawyers never argued the penalty for not obtaining insurance was a "tax," despite the Court's ruling that it could only be upheld under Congress' taxation powers.

"At no point did any of the government lawyers say it was a tax," LaBolt said, arguing the Obama team was being consistent in comparison to their GOP rivals.

Following the Court's ruling, many Republicans immediately pointed to the "tax" argument as evidence the president had raised taxes on the middle class. Obama's rival for the White House, however, was initially slow to label the mandate a "tax." A senior adviser for Mitt Romney, who initiated a similar provision while governor of Massachusetts, labeled the fee a "penalty" earlier this week.

On Wednesday Romney made clear he viewed the penalty as a "tax," contradicting his adviser, and that it represented a broken pledge by Obama to not raise taxes on the middle class.

In transcripts of the case's oral arguments, however, U.S. Solicitor General Donald Verrilli very clearly indicated the individual mandate could be viewed as constitutional under Congress' powers of taxation.

Verrilli said the fee "is administered by the IRS, it is paid on your Form 1040 on April 15th."

Asked by associate justice Samuel Alito "can the mandate be viewed as a tax," Verrilli responded "I think it could."

Obama Campaign national press secretary Ben LaBolt says President Obama maintains the health care mandate is a penalty.

In the additional clip below, CNN contributor Ryan Lizza challenges LaBolt's claim that the tax argument was not mentioned in the SCOTUS case.


Filed under: Health care
soundoff (2 Responses)
  1. Kaleb

    I really don't understand why news agencies are pressing the issue of tax versus penalty. There is some overlap between the terms tax and penalty anyway; it's not like they're completely separate things. This is essentially a penalty being levied by way of a tax. It really doesn't require much thought.

    July 6, 2012 at 12:31 am | Report abuse | Reply

Post a comment


 

CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.